top of page
5 min read

The Career Impact of Extraversion and Introversion: A Deep Dive

In the world of work, personality traits play a significant role in determining career outcomes. Among these traits, extraversion and introversion are particularly influential. This blog post explores the research on how these traits impact career success, job satisfaction, and job choices.

Extraversion and Career Success

Research has consistently shown that extraversion is linked to higher earnings and more frequent promotions. For instance, a study published in the Harvard Business Review found that an average individual will earn $600,000 more over a lifetime than a more introverted peer, a difference that corresponds to about 15% of lifetime earnings (HBR, 2018). This effect size is equally large for conscientiousness, another key personality trait.

Similarly, a study published in the Journal of Personality found that baseline extraversion predicted increases in income over a decade (Sage Journals, n.d.). Another study found that extraversion and conscientiousness were positively related to extrinsic success (Wiley Online Library, 1999).

The Sutton Trust analysis of BBC data found that highly extroverted people had a 25% chance of being in a higher-earning job (The Guardian, 2018). Moreover, extroverted employees were found to have greater satisfaction with salaries, promotions, and overall career satisfaction (Forbes, 2020).

Extraversion and Job Roles

Certain job roles seem to favor extroverts. For instance, roles in sales typically favor extroverts, with a study on salespeople finding that traits like emotional stability, optimism, and extraversion were closely tied to job and career satisfaction (ResearchGate, n.d.). Similarly, extraversion was found to be a valid predictor for occupations involving social interaction, such as managers and sales (Wiley Online Library, 1991). On the other hand, roles as analysts and individual contributors tend to favor introverts.

Extraversion, Introversion, and Education

Interestingly, extroverts are more likely to go to business school compared to STEM. A study found that students in different majors tend to have distinct personality traits, with business majors scoring higher in emotional stability and assertiveness (PMC, 2021). However, business school can be challenging for introverts due to the emphasis on group work, networking, and interviews (Forbes, 2020). There is also an intrinsic bias against introverts in business schools, which can affect their learning experience (The Globe and Mail, 2014).

Introversion and Remote Work

Introverts are more likely than extroverts to thrive and be satisfied with remote work. A study found that extroverted employees became less productive, less engaged, and less satisfied with their jobs over time in a remote work setting (Sage Journals, 2023). An article in The Washington Post (2021) also noted that introverts found remote work more comfortable, with 44% of U.S. workers preferring to work from home once restrictions are lifted.


Introverted Roles and Work Environments

While extroverts may thrive in roles that require a lot of social interaction, introverts often excel in roles that require deep focus, independent work, and thoughtful analysis. For instance, roles such as writers, software developers, accountants, and researchers often favor introverts. These roles require a high degree of concentration, attention to detail, and the ability to work independently - traits that introverts often possess.

Introverts also tend to thrive in quieter work environments. Open office layouts, which are designed to encourage collaboration and interaction, may be more challenging for introverts who prefer a quiet space for deep work. On the other hand, private offices or cubicles, remote work, or flexible work arrangements can be more conducive to introverts' productivity and job satisfaction.


Extraverts in Introverted Jobs

Extraverts doing introverted jobs are less likely to be happy, stay in the job, and get promoted. The shift from outside sales to inside sales, which favors introverts, is putting extroverts out of work (HBR, 2013).

Teamwork and Collaboration: Introverts vs. Extroverts

In terms of teamwork and collaboration, introverts and extroverts bring different strengths to the table. Extroverts are often seen as natural leaders in team settings due to their outgoing nature and ease in social situations. They can be great at motivating team members, facilitating discussions, and driving forward action.

Introverts, on the other hand, may be less vocal in team settings but they often excel in listening, providing thoughtful feedback, and working diligently behind the scenes. They can be highly effective leaders in a more one-on-one or small group setting, where they can build deep, meaningful relationships and provide individualized guidance and support.

Management Styles: Introverts vs. Extroverts

When it comes to management, extroverts and introverts also have different styles. Extroverted managers are often charismatic, energetic, and assertive. They are good at rallying their team, creating a dynamic and engaging work environment, and making quick decisions.

Introverted managers, on the other hand, may be more reserved and thoughtful. They often excel at listening to their employees, understanding their needs, and providing thoughtful and well-considered feedback. They may be more inclined to lead by example rather than command, and they often foster a calm and focused work environment.

Education and Career Paths: Introverts vs. Extroverts

In terms of education and career paths, introverts and extroverts may be drawn to different fields. As mentioned earlier, extroverts are often drawn to business-related fields, while introverts may be more likely to pursue careers in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM).

In conclusion, while there are general trends in how introversion and extraversion relate to career success and job satisfaction, it's important to remember that individual differences play a significant role. Introverts can also excel in business and leadership roles--Many successful CEOs and business leaders, such as Bill Gates and Warren Buffett, are self-proclaimed introverts. They have leveraged their introverted traits, such as deep focus, thoughtful analysis, and the ability to listen, to build successful careers in business. Both introverts and extroverts can find success and fulfillment in a wide range of careers, and the key is to find a career path and work environment that aligns with one's unique personality traits and strengths.

References

bottom of page